Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah? The question asked by millions of viewers and readers who have fallen in love with the story of “The Summer I Turned Pretty”. Although there is an ongoing debate on which brother is the best choice, the answer is, and always has been, Conrad. Although Jeremiah’s sweet and charismatic personality wins viewers over, his lustful choices and competitive nature against Conrad prove he was never “the one” for Belly. The series begins with background on each of the Fisher boys. Conrad, the mysterious, caring, smart, and truly loving older brother, and Jeremiah, the flirtatious, positive, and bold younger brother. Belly has loved Conrad her whole life, and Conrad all of his. While Jeremiah provides a distraction from the chaos caused by Conrad’s inability to communicate and emotional turmoil at the loss of his mother, ultimately Jeremiah proves to be the wrong choice. Throughout all three books, (and seasons one and two of the show), Jeremiah makes it painfully evident how much he feels at competition with Conrad, and even admits in season 2 that he saw how Belly looked at Conrad the previous summer, and was jealous that she didn’t look at Jeremiah like that. Conrad never had to compete for Belly’s love, and always was on her side even as children. Him teaching her to dance as shown in season one, winning her Junior Mint, and buying her the glass unicorn shown in season 2 with his allowance given to him as a child. Conrad, while complicated and difficult at times, loved Belly more than he knew capable. He pushed her away because he knew he was not good for her, and felt unable to be the person he knew he had to be for her. Book three, “We’ll Always Have Summer”, is truly when it’s revealed to the audience that Conrad is Belly’s real, true, and infinite love. Whether it be him remembering Laurel (Belly’s mother)’s favorite flowers when Jeremiah didn’t, always being on Belly’s side even if it meant watching her get married to Jeremiah, and even the letter Susannah wrote to her boys for their wedding days being switched. Also in “We’ll Always Have Summer”, Jeremiah cheats on Belly, and his flaws start to shine through to her. How he is not as mature as Conrad, does not have true life goals, and while admitting that he knows Belly will never love him like she loves Conrad, continues to attempt to go through with marriage to Belly. Conrad’s point of view in the third book of the series really portrays to the viewer just how long and how deeply he loves Belly, even if it’s hard for him to show that. The loss of his mother made his commitment issues and emotional vulnerability more difficult, which led to ongoing issues and conflict between him and Belly. While he dealt with these issues in unhealthy ways, he ultimately proves himself to be the better choice. In the show, even the simple song choices Jenny Han makes for Conrad and Jeremiah prove Conrad is the one. Conrad receives songs such as “Lover” , a classic love song, and “Invisible String”, which is about soulmates always being connected. Jeremiah receives “Delicate”, a song about lustful feelings carefully turning into potential real feelings. Jenny Han, the author of the series, is a huge Taylor Swift fan, and carefully chooses Taylor’s love songs for Conrad. Jeremiah and Belly’s relationship, especially in season two, is shown as purely physical, while Belly and Conrad are emotionally connected. This emotional connection is what makes Conrad the one for Belly.