Since 1962, when Spider-Man was introduced in the comics, he has been one of the most loved and iconic superheroes of all time. There have been many different variations of him and all have been unique in their own way. For years there has been a dispute as to who is the best Spider-Man. ‘Best’ can mean different things to different people, so this debate will focus on comic book accuracy and the actor’s depiction of the character. After analyzing all the aspects of the characters, there is an obvious choice for who is the superior Spider-Man.
To assess who is the best, it must be determined what makes Spider-Man, Spider-Man.
He gets his name from his spider-like strength, speed, and abilities. When it comes to strength, Holland takes this one with no question. In Spider-Man: Homecoming he holds together a ferry and, even though it is only for a few seconds, it is one of the most impressive feats out of all three Spider-Men. He also lifted a building off of himself near the end of the movie. The pinnacle of Maguire’s strength is seen in the train scene, and while that is impressive, it falls short in light of Holland’s show of strength. The best we got out of Garfield was him lifting a car. However, he does make up for that with his spider-like fighting moves and his great humor. He has the best quips and he makes funny comments during fights which is very accurate to the original character. Although Garfield is a great Spider-Man, he is not as great as Peter Parker.
All three Peter Parker's had money problems and complicated love lives which are kind of motifs in Peter’s life. Maguire most definitely had a hectic double life but he was a bit more serious and awkward. Garfield was almost not awkward enough and had a much more trendy, skater feel. While Maguire and Garfield were in their late twenties when they took the role, Holland was only nineteen. This really helps emphasize the innocence and youthfulness that is classic to the character. However, his movies are missing a key part of Peter Parker’s story; Uncle Ben. Tony Stark takes up the father figure role in his life and, while there was an Uncle Ben in his past, he has not been seen on screen.
Intelligence is another big part of Spider-Man’s characterization. All three movies show that intelligence but some movies focus on it more than others. Maguire is geeky and smart but nowhere near the genesis that Peter Parker should be. He doesn’t have Spider-Man’s quick wit or sarcasm. He also had organic webs instead of the classic homemade web shooters. Holland’s intelligence level is portrayed as more accurate in his movies. It is also stated that he is the smartest person at his school while Garfield was second only to Gwen Stacy. While both Holland and Garfield made their own webs, Holland also tailored his suit specifically to hone his enhanced senses.
Tobey Maguire did a good job at playing Peter Parker and will always be held in high regard for being the first one to bring the web-slinger to the big screen. Andrew Garfield made a more than satisfactory Spider-Man that was unique and had an unforgettable love story. Nevertheless, Tom Holland excels in both sides of the character. He has the geeky and loveable nature of Peter Parker while also having the confident and witty qualities of Spider-Man, pulling together what neither of the previous actors could. Holland understands that with great power comes great responsibility.