I have read a multitude of books throughout my life. Fiction, fantasy, non-fiction, science fiction, I am familiar with many genres. I have also seen many movie adaptations of some of my favorite novels and books. Most of these movie productions have ended up very cheesy, and downright disappointing. Now, this is not to say all movie productions are bad to my taste, but when it comes to The Chronicles of Narnia, the BBC version just doesn't quite cut it.
This being said, I do have a favorite that has stood the test of time, withstood critics, and has been loved by millions of raving fans. It might sound cliche, but my favorite movie adaptation of a novel series is none other than The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit. I have always had a very hard choosing favorites, there is no exception here. Not only is the quality of the end product incredible, but about every aspect of the show makes it more than simply very heartwarming. Though I have been told that these series are cheesy and have had extended discussions with friends concerning how LOTR cannot and should not ever be considered a favorite movie series, I still maintain my position that the many themes and underlying messages in these shows put these sagas in my number one spot on my movie shelf.
So, let's jump right in!
The main thing I want to discuss is the underlying theme of steadfast friendship and commitment that is shared between each of the bands of protagonists. In Lord of the Rings, you can see this undying commitment to one another through Aragorn's commitment to keeping Merry and Pippin safe after the breaking of the fellowship, it can be seen in the unlikely friendship that grows between Legolas and Gimli, the commitment of Bilbo to stay by Thorin's side, and most obvious of all the exemplary dedication shown by Sam to Frodo - even amidst the poisoning of Frodo's mind against Sam by Gollum. In the novels by Tolkien, there is very meticulous detail placed on the importance of each of these friendships that evolved through the most unlikely of circumstances. Though the books move rather slowly, this very careful detail given to each story line by the author ends up showing a beautiful connection between the characters. However, in the movie versions of the stories, these friendships are displayed in a much more touching and real way than the books could ever portray. The cinematography, graphics, music score, and even the finest details such as the lighting effect on the faces of the actors, all of these components bring to life each of the characters in more relatable ways, in more touching ways, and in a more personal way than that which Tolkien wrote the books with.
My experience reading these novels gave me the impression that each of these groups ended up with a very strong sense of brotherhood by the end of their journeys. The conversations they have with one another, the sacrifice that they each give up for the benefit and safety of each other, and the bonds that they all grew together were described subtly but consistently throughout the books. However, as the saying goes, one picture is worth a thousand words. The movies portray these same elements of friendship in different way than the books, and watching them, I would argue, gives a full rounded experience to the LOTR universe. Though the movies cannot fully replace the books, their complement to the overall story is irreplaceable, and with them the story feels complete.