These schools are similar to Carroll University in key aspects like size, setting, and academics.
100% of students
Carroll University has excellent academics and a lot of resources. Many options for writing assistance, and the multiple tutoring resources made available to students, someone struggling should have no problem finding the help they need. As for social life, Carroll is not a party school, but that is what makes it perfect for people who are still social but don't party a lot. People who do like to party will be satisfied, but people who don't will be just as satisfied.
The one thing to keep in mind is that Carroll has a small campus compared to some universities, which means they don't have a huge range of living options. However, Carroll does have a seniority requirement, as in you have to have senior standing in order to live off-campus. For me, this isn't a problem, but I know a lot of people who had difficulty with this policy, so it's definitely something to think about when considering Carroll.
I like the small class sizes, it makes getting extra time with the professors easier. There are lots of great programs, both social and academic.
Social life/nightlife outside of campus is limited, but it's close enough to Milwaukee to make the trip and have some fun on weekends and nights off.
It's a small place.
It's not varied in choices.
The programs are direct entry which saves students time and money when they decide on their major. The professors are also very passionate about their jobs.
The required classes for majors.